Decorative Logo

Coaching Session Playbook 

Posted on Sep 2, 2025

The Candorly Assessment offers clients insights into their workplace behaviors, strengths, and growth areas. As a coach, you help them interpret feedback, create action plans, and foster a growth mindset. Note: This guide assumes you received the report but weren’t involved in its creation.

Preparing for the Coaching Conversation

  • Review the Report & Identify Key Themes

Read the participant’s feedback report in full. Look for trends: strengths, growth opportunities, and gaps between self-perception and peer feedback (Perception Delta). This gap is key to unlocking self-awareness.

  • Frame Positively: 

Reinforce that feedback is a tool for development, not judgment.

Structuring the Discussion

  • Set Expectations

Start with why feedback matters: It’s a resource for growth, not performance management. Some participants may need help connecting feedback to behavioral change—remind them that strong leadership drives innovation, productivity, and business success.

  • Provide a Brief Overview 

Spend a minute explaining the report structure and scoring system.

  • Explore Initial Thoughts

Ask how they felt reading the report. Many will go through emotional stages (Kubler-Ross Change Curve). Normalize this as part of human nature.

  • Acknowledge Strengths & Growth Areas
    • Reinforce what they do well.
    • Use open-ended questions to explore feedback constructively (e.g., “What patterns do you notice?” “What surprised you?”).
  • Highlight the Perception Delta

Self-awareness is the foundation of leadership. Candorly’s Perception Delta—the gap between a participant’s self-score and their average feedback score—offers valuable insights into how participants see themselves versus how others perceive them. Make this a key part of your report discussion. Look for trends in their perception gap:

– Do certain areas show a significantly larger or smaller gap in self-awareness?

– Do they consistently rate themselves higher or lower than their feedback providers?

  • Encourage Reflection

 Ask the client to summarize key takeaways and their initial reactions.

Creating an Action Plan

  • Prioritize & Plan
    • Focus on one to two key areas. Encourage small, manageable steps rather than overwhelming change.
    • Align feedback with specific actions and practical behaviors (e.g., “To improve communication, I will seek clarification before assuming”).
    • Action planning in the first session will remain high-level as participants process the report. If there’s follow up coaching, a larger percentage of time will be spent on action planning. 
  • Build Accountability

Discuss progress measurement and who can support them.

Reinforcing a Growth Mindset

  • Normalize Feedback

Remind clients that constructive feedback is common for all professionals and an opportunity for growth. Moreover, as one grows as a leader, it’s a rare learning opportunity many professionals never get.

  • Reframe Challenges

Shift from “I’m bad at this” to “This is a skill I can develop.”

  • Encourage Ongoing Reflection

Suggest follow-ups like coaching, journaling, or peer discussions.

Next Steps & Follow-Up

  • Schedule a Follow-Up Coaching Session

Frame the initial report debrief as the first step in a three-phase process: insight, action, and accountability.

Session 1: Insight – Focus on the participant’s initial reaction to the report and key themes and learning opportunities. 

Session 2: Action – With time to reflect, this session shifts to helping develop specific behaviors to test in real-world scenarios. Coaches can help participants refine their plans, consider possible outcomes, and clarify what they hope to gain from these changes.

Session 3: Accountability – Participants reflect on their behavior experiments, what they learned, and how to sustain lasting change. This session also helps them plan for long-term accountability and support.

  • Offer Additional Resources: Recommend articles, books, or training aligned with their goals.

Final Thought

Your role as a coach is to foster curiosity, self-awareness, and action. Guide participants to embrace feedback, experiment with new behaviors, and take ownership of their development. Meaningful change happens through continuous learning and accountability—your coaching makes that possible.